Fixed indexed products, meaning fixed indexed annuities and indexed universal life insurance, credit interest based on the movement of a market index. When the index falls, the credit applied for that period is zero rather than negative. That is the floor, and it is real.
Here is the precise version: the floor applies to the index credit, not to your account value. Those are different numbers. A year with a zero credit is not automatically a year where nothing was lost, because the credit is only one of the things happening to the account.
With these products you do not own the index, you do not own shares, and you do not own any underlying security. The index is a reference used to calculate interest. One consequence people miss: you do not receive dividends paid by the companies in the index, and over long periods dividends are a meaningful share of what a stock index actually returns.
So the comparison that matters is not "indexed product versus the index." It is "indexed product versus the index's total return, minus the dividends you do not get, minus the upside the limits remove." Which brings us to the limits.
The floor is paid for. These are the mechanisms, and a given product will use one or more of them:
The insurer sets these, they vary by product and by crediting strategy, and the insurer can generally change them at its discretion subject only to the contractual minimums. The cap you are shown at purchase is not a promise for the life of the contract. Ask what the guaranteed minimum cap or maximum spread is, because that is the number you actually own.
This is where the two product types diverge sharply, and where most explanations stop too early.
A zero-credit year generally means flat. No growth, but the contract value does not fall from the index movement. That is close to what the sales language implies, and for a base contract it holds up.
Two things still cost you. Optional riders, such as a guaranteed income rider, carry annual charges that are deducted whether the index rose or not, so a contract with riders can decline in a flat year. And withdrawing early runs into surrender charges and possibly a market value adjustment. The floor protects against index loss. It does not protect against needing the money sooner than planned.
A zero-credit year is not flat, because the policy charges keep running regardless. Cost of insurance, premium loads, administrative and policy fees, rider charges, and interest on any outstanding loan all continue.
So in a zero-credit year, account value can fall. In several consecutive zero-credit years it can fall meaningfully. And cost of insurance rises with age, which means the drag grows over exactly the decades the strategy is supposed to be working.
An underfunded indexed policy can lapse. If it lapses or is surrendered while a loan is outstanding, the gain generally becomes taxable ordinary income that year, and the resulting tax bill can exceed any cash the policyholder ever received. That is the single most expensive failure mode in this entire category, and it does not announce itself. It shows up in year fourteen.
Sometimes, and the honest answer depends on what the money is for rather than on the product.
The floor is worth paying for when sequence matters more than average return. Money you will start drawing in the next ten years is in that category: a bad first few years of withdrawals does damage that a good average cannot undo. The floor is also worth something when the alternative is a client who panics and sells at the bottom, which is a real risk and not a hypothetical one.
The floor is a bad trade when the horizon is long, the money will not be touched, and the objective is maximum growth. Decades of capped participation against an uncapped index with dividends is a steep price for volatility you were never going to feel.
It is also a bad trade for anyone who cannot reliably fund the premium for the long term, because consistent funding is the thing that keeps an indexed life policy alive.
A product that survives those five questions may well be a good fit. A salesperson who deflects any of them has told you something useful.
A 0% floor means the index credit will not be negative. It does not mean the account cannot lose value, it does not mean the policy cannot lapse, and it does not mean you are getting the index's return minus nothing. It is a real feature with a real price, and the price is the upside you give up plus the charges that run regardless.
Anyone describing it as "you can't lose money" is either simplifying past the point of accuracy or has not read the contract. Both are worth knowing before you sign one.
Related
We will read the contract, model it in force, and tell you what it is actually doing. Sometimes the right answer is to keep it, and we will say so.
Request Your Strategy AuditThe percentages used above are illustrative arithmetic to show how caps, participation rates, and spreads work. They are not quotes, are not tied to any specific product, and are not a projection or guarantee of any result. Product features, rates, caps, participation rates, and spreads vary by carrier and by state and are subject to change. Guarantees are backed solely by the claims-paying ability of the issuing insurance company. This page is general education and is not tax, legal, or investment advice. See our full disclosures.